Buying a Home
Remortgaging
Landlord
Specialist
Secured Loans
Debt Consolidation
Conveyancing
Finding a Solicitor
Moving home
Both routes can get you a mortgage, but they come with different costs, market access, and advice protection. Here's a balanced, honest comparison to help you decide which suits your move.
Neither option is automatically better. Choosing between a mortgage broker and going direct to a lender depends on how complex your situation is, how much time you have to research the market, and how much support you want during the application.
A broker typically gives you an advised recommendation, with the broker taking responsibility for suggesting a suitable product. Going direct can be either advised or execution-only, which means you may carry more of the responsibility for choosing the right deal yourself.
If you're comparing mortgage broker vs going direct UK options, it helps to start with what a broker actually does. A mortgage broker is an intermediary who compares mortgage products from a wide range of lenders on your behalf, then recommends the option that best matches your income, deposit, and circumstances.
In the UK, mortgage brokers are authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Most broker sales are 'advised', meaning the broker takes responsibility for recommending a suitable product, rather than simply processing whatever you ask for.
Not all brokers have access to the same range of lenders. Some compare a wide range of the market, others work from a smaller panel of lenders, and some are tied to a single lender. It's worth understanding which type of broker you're dealing with before you commit.
If you're planning a house move, our moving home mortgage advice hub covers the wider process in more detail.
Broker types
Going direct means applying for a mortgage straight from a bank or building society, either online, over the phone, or in branch, without using a broker to compare the market for you.
Some direct applications are advised, where the lender's own mortgage advisor recommends a product from their own range. Others are execution-only, where you choose the product yourself and the lender simply processes your application without checking whether it's the most suitable option for you.
Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage or any other debt secured on it, so it's worth being confident in your choice before you apply, whichever route you take.
Weighing up your options
Talk through your circumstances with an advisor before you decide. There's no pressure to proceed either way.
The tables below set out how using a mortgage broker compares with going direct to a lender across the factors that matter most: market access, cost, advice, liability, speed, and regulatory protection.
If your income comes from more than one source, or you're self-employed with fluctuating profits, a broker can be genuinely useful. Lenders assess this kind of income very differently from one another, and knowing which lenders are comfortable with your exact situation can save a lot of wasted applications.
Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage or any other debt secured on it, whichever route you choose to apply through.
There's no single right answer to mortgage broker vs going direct - the better route depends on your own circumstances. Before comparing routes, it's worth knowing how much can I borrow? so you can weigh each option against a realistic budget. If you're dealing with credit issues specifically, our guide to a remortgage with bad credit covers that route in more depth.
If you're feeling unsure or overwhelmed by any part of the decision, MoneyHelper offers free, impartial guidance on 0800 138 7777.
Scenario guide
You're self-employed or a contractor
Lenders assess self-employed and contractor income very differently. A broker can identify which lenders are comfortable with your exact income structure.
You've had credit issues
Defaults, missed payments, or a county court judgement can rule you out with some lenders but not others. A broker can help you find lenders more likely to consider your application.
Your deposit is smaller
If you're working with a deposit under 15%, your options narrow. A broker can point you towards lenders that accept lower deposits for your circumstances.
Your purchase is more complex
Unusual property types, shared ownership, or schemes like Help to Buy often need a lender that specialises in that type of case.
You're new to the mortgage market
If this is your first time applying, having someone explain the process and check the recommendation is suitable can be reassuring.
Scenario guide
Broker fees vary. Some brokers do not charge you a fee directly for arranging your mortgage. Others charge a fee for their service, which is typically somewhere between a few hundred pounds and over a thousand pounds, depending on the complexity of your case and the broker's own pricing.
Before you commit to a broker, ask exactly how they charge, whether that's a fee, and get it confirmed in writing. A reputable broker will always be upfront about cost before you proceed.
Whether a fee is worth paying often comes down to how much time and effort it saves you, and whether it gives you access to a product or lender you wouldn't otherwise have reached. For straightforward cases, a broker that doesn't charge you a fee directly can make the broker route cost-neutral compared with going direct.
No, using a mortgage broker does not affect your credit score any more than going direct to a lender, provided the broker uses a soft search at the research stage. A soft search lets the broker check your likely eligibility with different lenders without leaving a mark that other lenders can see.
A hard search, which does appear on your credit file and can affect your score, only happens once you submit a full application to a specific lender. Whether that application comes through a broker or you apply direct makes no difference at that stage.
If you're comparing multiple lenders yourself by going direct, be cautious about how many full applications you submit, since each hard search can have a small impact on your credit file.
A broker may be able to access mortgage products that aren't available if you go direct, including deals that some lenders only offer through brokers. This doesn't mean a broker will always find you a cheaper rate than going direct, but it does mean you're seeing a wider set of options before you decide.
Broker fees, where they apply, are paid for the broker's service and don't change the interest rate a lender offers you. A lender's headline rate direct and the same lender's rate through a broker are generally the same, or close to it, for a given product.
The real advantage of a broker isn't necessarily a lower rate on any single product. It's the ability to compare more of the market and be matched to a product that's actually suitable for your circumstances, rather than settling for whatever one lender happens to offer.
Common questions
It depends on your circumstances. A broker tends to be more useful if you're self-employed, have credit issues, have a smaller deposit, or want help comparing a wide range of lenders. Going direct can work well if your income is simple, your deposit is large, and you're comfortable researching the market and completing the application yourself. Neither route is automatically cheaper or faster in every case, so it's worth thinking about what matters most to you: choice, support, or a simple process.
Yes, in some cases. A number of lenders only distribute certain mortgage products through brokers rather than offering them directly to the public, particularly deals aimed at more complex circumstances like self-employed applicants or those with adverse credit. This doesn't mean every broker-only deal will suit you, but it does mean going direct alone may not show you the full picture of what's available.
Timescales are similar either way, since both routes ultimately depend on the same lender processes and underwriting checks. A broker adds an initial step of comparing lenders and preparing your application, which can take a little longer upfront, but this is often offset by a more complete application that's less likely to be delayed by missing information. Going direct can feel quicker for very simple, straightforward cases, but a poorly prepared application can take just as long, or longer, to reach an offer.
Yes. Mortgage brokers operating in the UK must be authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority, either directly or as an appointed representative of an authorised firm. You can check a broker's status on the Financial Conduct Authority register before you proceed. Regulation means the broker is subject to rules on giving suitable advice, and you may have access to the Financial Ombudsman Service if something goes wrong.
If a broker gives you advice that turns out to be unsuitable, you can raise a complaint with the broker first. If it isn't resolved, you may be able to take your complaint to the Financial Ombudsman Service, which can review the case independently and, where appropriate, require compensation. This kind of protection generally isn't available if you applied direct to a lender on an execution-only basis, since no advice was given in the first place.
What our clients say
Shortly after I spoke with Anna, she was also very helpful and made it effortless and a nice experience.
Had a really good experience regarding arranging a secured loan. They introduced me to a great advisor. Thanks for the help.
For once a loan transaction without stress and complications. Very impressed and highly recommended.
Thrilled to share my exceptional experience with Money Saving Advisors. The website made it incredibly simple and easy to connect with an advisor. They helped me find the best deal on my remortgage and secured a very competitive interest rate!
Great advice and money saved on mortgage.
I have previously declined a loan of the value I needed from various brokers, but this website found me a reputable broker with surprisingly decent rates.
Mortgages
Compare mortgage rates from a wide range of lenders. Our expert advisors are here to help you find the right deal.
