Health Insurance

Health insurance brokers: what they do and how to choose one

A health insurance broker can compare private medical insurance from several insurers and help with underwriting, renewals and claims. See how brokers work, how they are paid, how to check one is authorised and when buying direct may be simpler.

  • See how a broker compares with buying direct or using a comparison site
  • Learn how brokers are paid and what they must tell you
  • Use the checklist of questions to ask before you choose
⚠

Policy terms, conditions, and exclusions apply. Not all treatments or pre-existing conditions are covered. Premiums may increase at renewal based on claims history and age.

What does a health insurance broker do?

A health insurance broker is an intermediary that arranges private medical insurance for you. Depending on its service, a broker may search many insurers or a set panel, explain how each policy treats your medical history and recommend cover that suits what you need and can afford.

  • Brokers are paid by commission included in your premium, by a fee you pay them directly, or by a mix of the two.
  • Before you buy, FCA rules require a broker to tell you how it is paid, whether it gives a personal recommendation and which insurers it can use.
  • You can check a broker on the FCA Firm Checker, and the Financial Ombudsman Service handles complaints a broker does not resolve.

A broker helps most if you have a medical history, want to switch insurer or are arranging cover for a business. Putting quotes from a few insurers next to each other is the clearest way to see how cover and price differ before you buy.

What a health insurance broker does

A health insurance broker, also called a private medical insurance broker, private health insurance broker or health insurance advisor, is a firm that arranges cover between you and an insurer. In regulatory terms it is an insurance intermediary, and it must be authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).

Before arranging a policy, the broker has to work out your demands and needs from what you tell it, and any cover it proposes must be consistent with them. You should receive a statement of those demands and needs before the contract starts. If the broker makes a personal recommendation, it must take reasonable care that the advice is suitable and explain why that policy meets your needs best.

In practice, a broker can help with:

  • Comparing policies: setting the hospital list, outpatient limit, cancer cover and excess of each policy side by side.
  • Underwriting: explaining how each insurer would apply moratorium or full medical underwriting to conditions you have had.
  • Renewals and claims: checking your renewal price against other insurers, and helping if a claim is delayed or refused, where this is part of the service.

A broker cannot change an insurer's rules. Whether a condition is covered, and at what cost, is set by each insurer's underwriting criteria, so much of a broker's value comes from knowing which insurers are likely to treat your history most favourably.

Sources checked in November 2026: FCA Handbook (ICOBS 5.2 and 5.3), FCA, Financial Ombudsman Service.

Health insurance broker vs going direct vs a comparison site

Buying direct means dealing with a single insurer, which quotes and explains its own policies only. A comparison site shows several prices at once, but the insurers listed and the help on offer vary by site. A broker compares insurers for you and can explain how each would treat your history.

Any firm that sells you a policy has to tell you whether it is giving a personal recommendation. If you buy with advice, the firm must check that the policy suits you. Without advice, it should give you enough information to decide for yourself. The guide to comparing health insurance quotes explains what to look at beyond the price.

Sources checked in November 2026: FCA Handbook (ICOBS 4.1 and 5.2), Financial Ombudsman Service.

Broker vs direct vs comparison site

Question
Broker / Direct / Comparison site
Who you deal with
A firm that arranges cover with one or more insurers / One insurer / A website showing quotes from the insurers it works with
How many insurers you see
The whole market or a named group of insurers, which the broker must disclose / One / The insurers listed on that site
Personal recommendation
If given, it must suit your needs / Only about its own policies / Depends on the site, which must say if it advises
How the seller is paid
Commission in the premium, a fee, or both, and it must tell you which / The insurer must tell you how its staff are paid for the sale / Depends on the site
Best suited to
Medical history, switching, families and business cover / Buyers who already know the insurer they want / Simple needs and a quick look at prices

How health insurance brokers are paid

Brokers are paid by commission, which is included in the premium you pay the insurer, by a fee you pay the broker directly, or by a combination of both. Some also receive other rewards from insurers, such as bonuses for reaching sales targets, profit share or enhanced commission.

Before you take out a policy, and at renewal where needed, the broker must tell you:

  • the nature of the payment it receives for your policy, which the FCA expects to include where the payment comes from;
  • the amount of any fee before you become liable to pay it, or how the fee is worked out if an exact amount cannot be given;
  • any fees that could be charged later, for example for changes during the year, administration or cancellation.

Commission is not shown as a separate charge because it sits inside the premium. If the disclosure is unclear, ask the broker to explain it.

The rules go further for business customers. A business can ask a broker how much commission it, and any associate, earns on a policy, and the broker must reply promptly, in writing and in cash terms, using an estimate if needed. The small business health insurance guide covers group schemes.

Sources checked in November 2026: FCA Handbook (ICOBS 4.3 and 4.4).

Want help choosing health insurance?

Answer a few questions and get matched with health insurance quotes for the cover you want. There is no pressure to proceed.

Independent, panel and tied brokers

Brokers do not all search the same number of insurers. Before you buy, a broker must tell you which of three kinds of service it offers. It must also say whether it acts for you or for the insurer, and whether it holds 10% or more of an insurer's voting rights or capital, or an insurer holds 10% or more of the broker.

A broker that uses a panel of insurers can still give fair analysis advice, as long as the panel is big enough, is reviewed regularly and is chosen on product features, premiums and service, not only on what benefits the broker. A tied broker can still be a good fit if its insurers are likely to accept you on fair terms, so ask for their names before you share your medical details.

Sources checked in November 2026: FCA Handbook (ICOBS 4.1 and 5.3).

Types of broker service

Type of service
What it means for you
Fair and personal analysis
The broker must look at a wide enough range of policies on the market before recommending one that meets your needs.
Tied to one or more insurers
The broker has a contract to place business only with certain insurers, and it must tell you their names.
Neither tied nor a fair analysis
The broker is free to use any insurer but does not analyse the wider market, and it must name the insurers it can and does use.

How to check a health insurance broker is authorised

  • Use the FCA Firm Checker. It shows whether a firm holds FCA authorisation and the permission needed to sell you the product it is offering. Make sure the firm reference number (FRN), phone number and website you have been given match the details listed, because scammers sometimes copy the name of a genuine firm.
  • Read the full record on the Financial Services Register. This official public record shows past fines and a firm's status on the date you took out a policy.
  • Check for appointed representative status. An appointed representative acts on behalf of an authorised firm, called its principal, which is responsible for that business. If the broker goes beyond what its principal allows, you could lose the protection of the Financial Ombudsman Service and the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS), so ask the principal what the broker can do.
  • Avoid firms that are not authorised. If a firm is only registered, or does not appear at all, you are unlikely to have access to the Ombudsman or the FSCS if things go wrong.

If an authorised broker that arranged your health insurance fails, the FSCS can step in for eligible claims. For general insurance that is not compulsory, such as private medical insurance, protection is 90% of the claim (FSCS insurance protection).

The British Insurance Brokers' Association (BIBA) also runs a Find Insurance service where you can search by postcode for brokers that arrange private medical insurance, with BIBA members marked.

Sources checked in November 2026: FCA, Financial Services Compensation Scheme, British Insurance Brokers' Association.

Questions to ask a health insurance broker

Use this checklist in your first conversation, and ask for the answers in writing.

  • Authorisation: ask for the firm reference number and whether the firm is directly authorised or an appointed representative.
  • Insurers: ask whether its advice rests on a fair analysis of the whole market or on a set list of insurers, and ask for their names.
  • Pay: ask how it is paid for your policy, the amount of any fee and whether charges apply for changes or cancellation.
  • Who it acts for: ask whether it acts on your behalf or for the insurer.
  • Underwriting: ask which type of underwriting it suggests for your medical history, and which conditions are likely to be excluded.
  • Switching: if you already have cover, ask whether a new insurer would accept you on your current terms, and what extra questions or exclusions could apply.
  • Cover details: ask how each policy's hospital list, outpatient limit, cancer cover and excess compare.
  • Hospitals: ask which hospitals each policy lets you use, then look them up on PHIN, the independent, government mandated body that publishes information on private hospitals and consultants.
  • After the sale: ask whether it reviews your policy at renewal and helps if a claim is delayed or refused.
  • Complaints: ask how to complain to the firm, and confirm that complaints it cannot resolve can be referred to the Financial Ombudsman Service.

Sources checked in November 2026: FCA Handbook (ICOBS 4.1 and 4.3), Private Healthcare Information Network (PHIN).

When a broker helps most, and when going direct is simpler

  • Pre-existing conditions: some policies are individually underwritten, so the insurer asks about your health and tells you which declared conditions are covered. Others exclude pre-existing conditions as a group. A broker can tell you which approach suits your history. See the pre-existing conditions guide.
  • Choosing underwriting: moratorium underwriting skips the full medical history at the application stage, and your GP may be asked for details at claim time. Full medical underwriting means filling in a health questionnaire, so you know what is excluded before cover starts. Read more on moratorium underwriting and full medical underwriting.
  • Switching insurer: if your current policy uses moratorium underwriting, you can usually move on the same basis. If it used full medical underwriting, a new insurer may carry your existing exclusions across, known as continued personal medical exclusions (CPME). Expect a few health questions and possibly new exclusions, so let a broker check which insurers would accept you before you cancel anything. The guide to switching health insurance has more detail.
  • Over 50s and over 65s: compare how each insurer would treat conditions you have had, as well as the price. The over 65s health insurance guide explains cover in later life.
  • Small businesses: workplace schemes can offer underwriting that is usually not open to individuals, such as medical history disregarded, which covers conditions employees already have. With a group policy the employer is the policyholder, so a complaint about how it was sold has to come from the employer. See the best business health insurance providers.

Going direct can be simpler when you already know which insurer you want or have little medical history to explain. An insurer selling direct still has to check that the cover is consistent with your needs and tell you whether it is giving a personal recommendation.

Whichever route you take, compare cover as well as price. The best health insurance providers and cost of health insurance guides show how insurers and premiums differ.

Sources checked in November 2026: Financial Ombudsman Service, WPA, AXA Health, Vitality, FCA Handbook (ICOBS 4.1 and 5.2).

Using a broker, from quote to claim

  • Answer every question carefully. The law expects you to take reasonable care not to give an insurer misleading information. If an answer later proves wrong, the insurer may charge more, restrict the policy, pay only part of a claim, or cancel the policy and decline any claim. This still applies when a broker fills in the form with you, so check every answer before it is sent.
  • Read the demands and needs statement. Make sure it reflects what you told the broker, such as the hospitals you want and any conditions you mentioned. With a recommendation, you should also get an explanation of why that policy was chosen for you.
  • Review at renewal. Ask the broker to check the renewal price against other insurers and to confirm which underwriting terms you would keep if you moved.
  • If something goes wrong. Complain to the firm first. Most firms have up to eight weeks to send a final response, and if you are still unhappy you then have six months from that response to bring it to the free Financial Ombudsman Service. If it finds a broker sold you an unsuitable policy, it may ask the broker to pay compensation.

When you are ready, a set of quotes from different insurers shows how cover and price differ before you commit.

Sources checked in November 2026: Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012, Financial Ombudsman Service, FCA Handbook (ICOBS 5.2 and 5.3).

Common questions

Frequently asked questions

A broker saves you approaching insurers one by one. It can compare policies, explain how each would treat your medical history and, if it advises you, recommend cover that suits your needs. For health insurance this helps most with existing conditions, switching, or cover for a family or business.

Not always. A broker can only offer prices from the insurers it works with, and it is paid by commission included in the premium, a fee, or both. It may find better value by matching your needs to the right insurer, so compare its quotes with a direct quote.

A broker may search only a set list of insurers or be tied to one, and the way it is paid can influence what it suggests. It must tell you how it is paid, which insurers it uses and whether it acts for you or the insurer, so ask about all three.

If you already know which insurer you want, its own team can explain its policies. To compare several insurers, an FCA authorised broker can do the legwork and, if it gives advice, recommend a policy. Check any firm on the FCA Firm Checker before you share medical details.

Through commission included in your premium, a fee you pay directly, or both. Some also receive bonuses or profit share from insurers. Before you buy, the broker must tell you the nature of its pay and the amount of any fee, including fees that could apply later.

A broker paid only by commission does not send you a separate bill, because the commission is included in the premium you pay the insurer. If a broker charges a fee, it must tell you the amount before you are committed to paying it.

Search for the firm on the FCA Firm Checker or the Financial Services Register, and make sure the firm reference number, phone number and website match. If it is an appointed representative, its principal is responsible for its work.

Yes, mainly by finding the insurers and underwriting type that treat your history best. What is covered is decided by each insurer. If you already have a policy, a broker can check whether a new insurer would accept you on continued terms rather than starting again.

Compare health insurance quotes

Get quotes matched to your cover needs, with no obligation.

What our clients say

Reviews from real customers

"Clear, Thorough and Empathetic"

Shortly after I spoke with Anna, she was also very helpful and made it effortless and a nice experience.

5/5
Tyler Elsworthy

"Helped us make an informed decision"

Had a really good experience regarding arranging a secured loan. They introduced me to a great advisor. Thanks for the help.

5/5
Dana Huggins

"Highly recommnded"

For once a loan transaction without stress and complications. Very impressed and highly recommended.

5/5
Alex Pearce

"Exceptional service from start to finish"

Thrilled to share my exceptional experience with Money Saving Advisors. The website made it incredibly simple and easy to connect with an advisor. They helped me find the best deal on my remortgage and secured a very competitive interest rate!

5/5
Aaron Humphreys
GB

"Great advice and money saved"

Great advice and money saved on mortgage.

5/5
Ace
GB

"Very helpful and professional"

Very helpful and professional. Sorted out all the necessary paperwork and chased people when needed. We have actually recommended her to a family member

5/5
Miles Storrs

This article was written by:

Lawrence Howlett
Lawrence Howlett

Founder of Money Saving Advisors

Lawrence Howlett brings a results-driven mindset to his writing, shaped by over a decade of experience across finance, legal, and energy sectors. As the founder of Moneysavingadvisors, he’s built a reputation for turning complex financial concepts into clear, actionable insights for consumers. His writing stands out for its clarity, structure, and focus on delivering value.

Article last updated 20 November 2026

Reviewed by Nick McDonald on 20 November 2026