High Street Banks vs Specialist Lenders – Secured Loans in the UK
Compare high street bank secured loans with specialist secured loan lenders in the UK. Learn about rates, eligibility, fees, and second charge mortgage options.
Related articles
Why Comparing Lenders Matters
UK homeowners with a mortgage often reach a point where they need to borrow a large amount – whether it’s for consolidating multiple debts into one payment, financing a major home improvement, or covering an important life expense. In these situations, a secured loan (also known as a second charge mortgage) can be an attractive alternative to remortgaging or taking out unsecured loans. However, deciding where to get a secured loan is crucial. Should you approach a familiar high street bank, or would a specialist secured loan lender be a better fit?
This guide compares high street banks and specialist lenders in the UK for second charge homeowner loans, helping you understand the differences. By the end, you’ll have a clearer picture of which route might suit your needs and how to go about comparing deals. (All examples are illustrative; actual rates and terms depend on your circumstances and each lender’s assessment.)
High street banks and specialist lenders both offer secured loans, but their approaches, criteria, and products can differ significantly. Let’s explore how.
Need to decide fast? Check your secured loan options with specialist lenders via our comparison tool – it won’t affect your credit score.
High Street Banks and Secured Loans – What They Offer
High street banks – household names like Barclays, HSBC, Lloyds Bank, NatWest/RBS, Santander, TSB, and Nationwide Building Society – are usually the first stop for many looking for mortgages or personal loans. But when it comes to secured loans from high street banks, their offerings are often limited.
The High Street Names and Their Approach
Not all high street banks provide second charge mortgages directly. Many prefer to offer further advances (additional borrowing on an existing first mortgage) or unsecured loans, rather than separate second charge loans. Here’s how some major banks handle secured lending:
- Barclays – Typically offers further advances to existing mortgage customers but does not market a separate second charge mortgage product. If you enquire about a stand-alone secured loan, Barclays may refer you to a specialist broker or another lender.
- HSBC – Focuses on unsecured personal loans and additional borrowing on HSBC mortgages. As of now, HSBC UK does not have a dedicated second charge mortgage range.
- Lloyds Bank – Allows further advances on Lloyds mortgages for things like home improvements, but it doesn’t offer a direct secured second charge loan to new customers. They often refer second charge enquiries to specialist partners or brokers.
- NatWest/RBS – Similar to Lloyds, they provide additional borrowing to existing mortgage clients but no standalone NatWest second charge mortgage available to the broader market.
- Santander – Offers a secured homeowner loan product in limited cases, typically for its own mortgage base. Often, Santander will encourage a remortgage or further advance instead of a true second charge.
- Nationwide Building Society – Nationwide primarily offers further advances on its mortgages. It doesn’t advertise separate second charge loans to external customers.
- TSB – TSB may consider additional borrowing for those with TSB mortgages, but like others, doesn’t actively offer second charge loans to the general public.
High street banks offering secured loans tend to do so only for their existing mortgage customers, and even then, through additional borrowing rather than a classic second charge mortgage separate from the first mortgage.
How High Street Banks Handle Secured Loans
When a high street bank does consider a second charge or any large secured loan, they usually have stricter criteria and a narrower scope:
- Preference for existing customers: Banks are more likely to approve a secured loan (or further advance) if you already have your first mortgage with them and have a solid repayment history. This makes it easier to assess risk.
- Conservative lending amounts: High street bank secured loan amounts are often limited compared to specialist lenders. For example, a bank might cap additional borrowing at, say, £50,000 or a certain Loan-to-Value (LTV) ratio (often 75%-85% total borrowing against the property).
- Shorter terms: Banks typically offer terms of around 3–10 years for a secured homeowner loan or further advance. This is shorter than what many specialists can do (which can go up to 25-30 years).
- “Tick-box” underwriting: Traditional lenders use strict credit scoring and income criteria. They usually require a clean credit history, stable PAYE income, and may decline self-employed applicants without extensive records. In other words, high street bank secured loan eligibility is highest for “prime” customers with vanilla profiles.
- Second charge vs further advance: A true second charge mortgage from a bank is rare; more often they’ll extend a further advance on your existing mortgage. The effect (using home equity as security) is similar, but a further advance keeps all borrowing with the same lender as one combined mortgage account (split into two sub-accounts perhaps), whereas a second charge is a separate loan with its own terms.
Example: Barclays (through its partner or mortgage division) might offer a secured loan from ~£10,000 upwards for existing borrowers, with representative APRs around 6%–12% over up to 10 years. Santander’s “homeowner loan” for its customers might start around £5,000. These are competitive rates, but not everyone will qualify.
Pros of Using a High Street Bank
Choosing your bank or building society for a secured loan can have some advantages:
- Lower headline interest rates: For those with excellent credit scores and low debts, high street banks may offer secured loan rates on the lower end (perhaps even under 6% APRC). They have access to cheaper funding, so high street bank secured loan rates (UK) can be very attractive – but only if you fit their criteria.
- Familiar, trusted brands: Many borrowers feel more comfortable dealing with a well-known bank. You likely already have a relationship or account, which builds trust. These institutions have established customer service and are backed by robust regulations.
- Convenience for existing customers: If your current mortgage is with the bank, a further advance might be straightforward. There’s less paperwork on property details since they already hold your information. You might even manage the new loan through your existing online banking.
- Regulated and protected: High street banks are all regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). If something goes wrong, you have the reassurance of formal complaints procedures and access to the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS).
Cons of Using a High Street Bank
On the other hand, there are clear drawbacks to sticking with a high street lender for a secured loan:
- Limited availability of products: As noted, secured loans from high street banks are not widely marketed. If your bank doesn’t offer second charge mortgages (which many don’t), you may simply be out of luck unless you remortgage. This limits your options.
- Stricter eligibility: Banks typically won’t approve secured loans for bad credit situations. If you have missed payments, a history of adverse credit, or an unconventional income (like self-employed with variable earnings), a high street bank may decline your application. They cater to prime borrowers first and foremost.
- Lower loan-to-value allowed: Banks are cautious. They might only lend up to, say, 75% LTV when combining your first mortgage and second charge. Specialist second charge mortgage lenders might go higher (some up to 95% LTV in certain cases). So the maximum you can borrow from your bank could be lower than what a specialist would offer.
- Potentially slower process: Big banks often have multiple departments. A second charge request might need to go through extra approval layers, especially if it’s not routine business for them. This can make the process slower, whereas specialists streamline secured loan applications as their core business.
- Focus on remortgaging: Often when you ask your bank about borrowing more, they’ll recommend a remortgage or further advance. This might not be in your best interest if it means losing a great rate on your existing mortgage or incurring early repayment charges. Banks generally won’t tell you about competitor options, whereas a secured loan broker could.
Tip: If your bank offers you a further advance, compare the total cost and impact on your first mortgage vs a second charge with another lender. It’s wise to compare what you could borrow outside your bank – you might find a more flexible deal elsewhere. Compare secured loans with other lenders before committing.
Specialist Secured Loan Lenders – A Different Approach
In contrast to high street banks, specialist secured loan lenders in the UK focus on second charge mortgages (and related products) as their primary business. These lenders operate either directly to consumers or through brokers and intermediaries. They are sometimes smaller banks, building societies, or finance companies without high street branches. What they offer is a different approach that can benefit those who don’t fit the strict mould of a high street bank customer or who need a more tailored solution.
Who Are the Specialist Lenders?
There’s a range of specialist second charge mortgage lenders in the UK. Some of the prominent names include:
- Pepper Money – A specialist lender known for considering borrowers with complex income or past credit issues. Pepper offers second charge mortgages and is more lenient on credit score hiccups.
- Norton Home Loans – A long-established provider of secured loans for homeowners including those with adverse credit. Norton offers various products and will look at cases high street banks decline.
- Selina Finance – Offers a modern take on secured lending, including flexible drawdown facilities (like a secured line of credit) using your home equity. Good for those who want to borrow in stages.
- Together Money – A lender offering second charge loans and even bridging finance, known for bespoke underwriting on unique cases (e.g., unusual properties or complex income).
- Masthaven Finance – (Recently a bank but winding down retail operations) Historically provided specialist mortgages and second charges, including for the self-employed.
- Central Trust – Offers homeowner secured loans up to 30 years, with variable interest options and a willingness to accept varying credit profiles.
- United Trust Bank (UTB) – A specialist bank that provides second charge mortgages among other niche finance products, often via brokers.
- Equifinance – Specialises in adverse credit secured loans, willing to lend to those with poor credit histories at higher rates.
- Believe Loans – Not a lender, but a notable broker/loan platform. Believe Loans works with over 90+ lenders (including many of the above specialists). It’s relevant because through one application you can access a wide panel of direct secured loan lenders UK. Essentially, it’s a way to see secured loans from specialist lenders side by side.
These specialist lenders don’t have high street branches; you won’t typically see their ads on TV or a local billboard. Instead, you might find them through a broker, an online search, or a referral from a financial advisor. All are authorised and regulated by the FCA, just like banks, so they must follow the same rules on responsible lending and treating customers fairly.
How Specialist Lenders Operate
Specialist lenders operate with a different philosophy from mainstream banks:
- Focus on second charges: They concentrate on second charge mortgages, secured homeowner loans, and related products. This means their teams, processes, and systems are built to handle those applications efficiently – it’s not an afterthought as it might be at a bank.
- Flexible underwriting: Instead of a strict tick-box approach, specialists often take a case-by-case view. They might accept self-employed income with only one year of accounts, consider borrowers with a few defaults or late payments (at a higher rate), and listen to explanations for past credit problems. In short, they are more open to bad credit secured loans and non-standard situations.
- Broader credit band acceptance: Specialists have tiers for different credit profiles – prime, near-prime, subprime. So even if you have a low credit score or past issues, you might fall into a category they can price for (albeit at a higher interest rate). High street banks typically have just one category: prime.
- Larger loans and longer terms: Many specialist lenders will lend from £5,000 up to £500,000+ as a second charge, depending on your home value and equity. They also offer longer repayment terms, often up to 25 or 30 years, which can significantly lower monthly payments on a large loan (though you may pay more interest overall).
- Higher loan-to-value (LTV): Some specialist secured loans go up to 85%, 90%, even 95% LTV of your property’s value (combined with your first mortgage). This means if you have little equity, a specialist might still lend – something a bank would likely reject.
- Speed and service: Because it’s their core business, specialist lenders often provide faster initial decisions. Many work closely with brokers who package your application, making the underwriting smoother. It’s not unusual to get a second charge completed in 2–4 weeks with a specialist, whereas a bank’s internal process might drag out if unfamiliar.
- Use of brokers: Most specialists operate via intermediaries. So, you might not apply to them directly yourself; instead, a secured loan broker vs direct lender choice comes into play. Brokers like Believe Loans, Loans Warehouse, or Freedom Finance gather your info and then find a lender match. This all-of-market access often yields better results than going direct to one specialist, unless you’re sure which one fits you best.
Pros of Specialist Secured Loan Lenders
Working with a specialist second charge lender (directly or through a broker) can offer several key advantages:
- Wider range of products: Unlike banks, specialists collectively offer a huge variety of secured loans. Whether you need a debt consolidation secured loan, a homeowner loan for home improvements, or a niche product (like a buy-to-let second charge or a short-term bridging-style second charge), there’s likely a specialist that provides it. You’re not limited to one bank’s narrow menu.
- Greater flexibility in criteria: Specialists are the go-to choice for secured loans for self-employed individuals, people with irregular incomes, or those with past credit blips. They will consider adverse credit second charge mortgages – for example, if you have a CCJ or defaults, some lenders (like Pepper Money or Equifinance) might still approve a loan at a higher interest rate. This flexibility can be a lifesaver if a high street bank has turned you away.
- Higher borrowing possible: Need a large sum? Specialists won’t blink at loans well over £100,000 if you have the equity and can afford repayments. They’re experienced in large homeowner secured loan UK cases (e.g., £200k for business purposes or £150k for extensive home renovations). Banks often have lower caps for non-first-mortgage borrowing.
- Longer repayment terms: As mentioned, being able to spread a loan over 20-30 years can make the monthly cost much easier to manage. Specialists give you that option. For example, a 15-year term on a second charge for debt consolidation can reduce the monthly payment strain compared to a 5-year bank loan, though you must weigh the extra interest paid over time.
- Dedicated service: Many specialist lenders or the brokers representing them provide a more personal service. You might get a single case manager or advisor handling your application, keeping you informed throughout. Because they’re eager for business in this niche, they often go the extra mile to assist and expedite cases.
- Keep your first mortgage intact: By taking a second charge with a specialist, you avoid disturbing your existing mortgage. This is crucial if your current mortgage has a great low rate or has an early repayment charge. A second charge lets you borrow additional funds without remortgaging – specialists make this possible even when banks won’t.
Cons of Specialist Lenders
Naturally, there are some downsides to consider with specialist secured loan lenders:
- Higher interest rates for some: If you fit a prime profile, a high street bank (if available) might offer a lower rate than a specialist. Specialist lenders tend to have interest rates ranging widely based on risk – from competitive ~6% APRs for very safe borrowers, up to 20%+ APR for those with poor credit. So, a well-qualified borrower could find a cheaper deal through a bank or further advance. It’s important to compare secured loan interest rates UK across both.
- Additional fees: With specialists, you’ll often encounter broker fees, lender arrangement fees, and possibly a valuation fee for your property. These can add up to hundreds or even over a thousand pounds. High street banks may charge minimal or no upfront fees (especially for a further advance). Be sure to factor in the fees when comparing secured loan fees: high street banks vs specialist lenders. However, note that many fees can often be added to the loan instead of paid upfront (which means you’ll pay interest on them).
- Less brand recognition: You might not have heard of some specialist lenders before. This unfamiliarity can make some borrowers uneasy. Rest assured, any reputable specialist lender will be FCA-regulated and follow UK law – but they don’t have the centuries-old brand presence of, say, Lloyds or Barclays.
- Variable rates and terms: Some specialist loans come with variable interest rates (often tracking the Bank of England base rate or a lender’s own standard rate). This means your rate (and payment) could go up over time. Fixed-rate options are available too, but they might be for shorter periods (e.g., a 5-year fix on a 15-year loan). Always check if the rate is fixed or variable, and what the implications are.
- Early repayment charges: Many specialist second charge mortgages have early repayment charges (ERCs) especially in the initial years or if you fix the rate. If you think you might clear the loan early or refinance, look for a deal with low or no ERCs. High street bank further advances might be more flexible on this front (depending on the mortgage product).
- Complexity: When using a broker and dealing with a new lender, the process can feel a bit more complex than simply clicking “Apply” on your online banking. There will be separate paperwork, and you have two loans on the property instead of one. It’s manageable, but you need to stay organised with two commitments.
Want to see some of the top specialist lenders and their current secured loan deals? See our top-rated specialist secured loans lenders to get an idea of options beyond the high street.
Side-by-Side Comparison – High Street vs Specialist Lenders
To highlight the differences between taking a second charge mortgage vs a bank loan (secured loan) in the UK, let’s compare high street banks and specialist lenders on key factors:
Eligibility & Credit Criteria
- High Street Banks: Designed for prime borrowers. You’ll typically need a good/excellent credit score, a solid repayment history, and a straightforward income (PAYE job or a very well-documented self-employment). Banks often require you to be an existing mortgage customer for a secured loan or further advance. If you have any significant credit issues (recent defaults, CCJs, high unsecured debts), mainstream banks are likely to decline your application. In short, high street bank secured loans for bad credit are extremely rare.
- Specialist Lenders: Much more forgiving and flexible. They cater to a spectrum of credit profiles – from prime to subprime. Self-employed with one year of accounts? There’s a specialist for that. Missed a few credit card payments last year? A specialist might overlook it or just charge a higher rate. The eligibility bar is lower: they’ll consider debt consolidation cases, people with past mortgage arrears (if resolved), and other scenarios banks would shy away from. Essentially, if you don’t qualify with a bank, a specialist second charge mortgage lender is your Plan B (and often Plan A).
Loan Amounts & Terms
- High Street Banks: Loan amounts for second charges or further advances are typically on the smaller side. Depending on the bank, you might borrow from around £5,000 up to £100,000 (and the higher end usually only for those with high incomes and lots of equity). Terms offered are often between 3 to 10 years for a secured loan segment. Some banks might go to 15 years, but it’s not common. They also limit the total loan-to-value – many won’t let your combined mortgage + second charge exceed ~75-85% of your property value.
- Specialist Lenders: They truly cover the gamut of secured loan sizes. You can find specialists willing to lend as little as £5,000, but also those comfortable with £300,000 or more. If you have a high-value property and strong equity, large loans are possible. Terms are flexible – common offerings include 5, 10, 15, 20, even 30 years. This means you could opt for a shorter term to pay it off quicker or a very long term to minimise monthly payments. And as mentioned, some specialists allow higher LTVs (90% or more in select cases), which can enable borrowing where a bank says you don’t have enough equity.
Interest Rates & Fees
- High Street Banks: Generally offer lower interest rates to those who qualify, because they cherry-pick the lowest-risk customers. If you’re a prime borrower, you might get a rate quote in the mid single digits (e.g., 4–6% APRC) on a further advance or secured loan from a bank. Additionally, banks often have minimal fees – for example, no separate product fee for a further advance (it might just be added to your mortgage account) and possibly free property valuation. The cost structure is simpler: you pay interest and maybe an admin fee, but not much else.
- Specialist Lenders: Rates vary widely. Specialist secured loan interest rates are risk-based, ranging from competitive (near bank rates) for top-notch cases to quite high (teens or 20% APR) for poor credit cases. It’s crucial to get a UK second charge mortgage comparison of rates tailored to you. Fees are usually higher: expect an arrangement fee (often around 1-2% of the loan, sometimes capped), a broker fee if you use one (maybe £500 to £1,500 or a commission built into the rate), and a valuation fee (often £100-£300 for a drive-by valuation, more if a full survey is needed). There could also be legal fees, though second charge legal work is often simpler and sometimes included in the arrangement fee. Always request a breakdown of all fees from any specialist lender or broker – transparency is required by the FCA.
Application Process & Speed
- High Street Banks: If you’re getting a further advance on your existing mortgage, the process might be handled by the bank’s mortgage department. It could be relatively quick if straightforward – maybe a couple of weeks – but if the bank doesn’t often do second charges, it might involve multiple steps. You’ll likely have an appointment or call with an advisor, and they’ll run an affordability check similar to a mortgage application. Speed-wise, banks can be slower especially if the loan requires separate processing. Many bank customers report that securing a further advance or second charge can take over a month, partly due to the bank’s internal bureaucracy.
- Specialist Lenders: Specialists (and the brokers working with them) aim to make the process as streamlined as possible – this is their selling point. After an initial soft credit check to show you what’s possible, a full application triggers a hard credit search and underwriting. A property valuation is arranged (often quickly, using automated valuation models or a visit from a surveyor). Since these lenders only do secured loans, they have dedicated teams, so you often get to completion in 2-4 weeks from application if all documents are in order. Some simpler cases (lower LTV, straightforward credit) can even complete in under 2 weeks. You’ll typically deal with a single point of contact (e.g., a case manager) who keeps things moving. Overall, specialists know you want the money soon – and they’re motivated to lend – so they push to complete faster than a high street bank’s more cautious pace.
Next step: If you’re unsure where you fit, consider speaking to a secured loan broker who can compare high street and specialist secured loan lenders for you. They’ll quickly assess your profile and tell you which route is likely to offer the better deal. You can also check your eligibility for specialist secured loans with a quick online form.
Typical Costs and Representative Examples
When taking out a secured loan – whether from a bank or a specialist – it’s important to understand the total cost, not just the interest rate. Because these are large, long-term loans, the interest can add up, and there may be additional charges.
Interest and Total Repayable: Unlike a first mortgage which might be over 25+ years, a second charge loan could be shorter. Even so, because you might be borrowing tens of thousands of pounds, the total interest over the life of the loan can be significant. Always look at the APRC (Annual Percentage Rate of Charge) and the total amount repayable in the loan illustration. The APRC factors in fees and interest to give you an equivalent yearly rate.
For example, suppose a high street bank offers a homeowner (with good credit) a £30,000 further advance at 5% interest over 10 years. The monthly payment would be around £318, and the total repaid over 10 years would be roughly £38,200 (including interest). In comparison, a specialist lender might approve the same £30,000 over 15 years at, say, 8% for someone with a few credit issues. The monthly payment would drop to about £287, but over 15 years the total repaid would be approximately £51,600. That’s a much higher total cost, showing how a longer term and higher rate increase what you pay back overall.
Representative example (specialist lender): Borrow £50,000 over 20 years at a representative APRC of 7.9% (variable). Estimated monthly payment £414.79. Total amount repayable £99,549 (includes interest and a £1,000 arrangement fee). This example illustrates that the total repayable is nearly double the amount borrowed when spread over a long term – a common outcome for long-term loans. (This is just an example; actual rates vary.)
Fees: As discussed, specialists may charge various fees. It’s important to clarify which fees are added to the loan (capitalized) versus paid upfront out-of-pocket. Added fees will accrue interest but won’t dent your savings immediately. Some typical fees on a second charge mortgage in the UK:
- Lender arrangement fee: e.g. £295 up to 2% of the loan (sometimes waived for promotions).
- Broker fee: e.g. £500 or a percentage of the loan (often negotiable; some brokers zero-fee and take commission from lender instead).
- Valuation fee: e.g. £150 for a basic drive-by valuation, more for full survey; some lenders waive this below a certain LTV or use automated valuations for free.
- Legal fee: much smaller than for a house purchase, but there might be a £100-£300 charge for the solicitor or lender’s legal work in securing the second charge.
- Telegraphic transfer fee: e.g. £30 for sending the money to you on completion.
Always request a Secured Loan Key Facts Illustration (KFI) or ESIS (European Standardised Information Sheet) which will list all applicable fees and the terms. By law, lenders and brokers must provide this before you commit. And remember: if anything is unclear, ask questions. A secured loan is a big commitment, so you should understand every penny of cost.
Early Repayment Charges (ERCs): Check if your loan has an ERC. Many second charge loans have an ERC that might be a fixed fee or a percentage of the balance if you clear the loan within a certain period (often the first 3–5 years, or during a fixed-rate period). High street bank further advances sometimes simply fall under your main mortgage’s ERC schedule. Knowing this matters because if you plan to sell your home or refinance everything in the near future, an ERC could add cost.
(For a deeper dive into typical rates and fees, see “Secured loan interest rates and charges” which explains how APRC is calculated and what to watch out for.)
Regulation, Consumer Protection and Complaints
Whether you choose a high street bank or a specialist lender for your secured loan, you have important protections as a consumer in the UK.
All the lenders and brokers mentioned here are authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). This means they must adhere to strict rules on responsible lending, treating customers fairly, and transparency of information. Second charge mortgages used to fall under separate consumer credit rules, but now they are regulated like first mortgages, offering robust consumer protection.
Key points on regulation and protection:
- FCA Authorisation: You can check any lender or broker’s credentials on the FCA Register (an online database). If a company isn’t listed as authorised for mortgages or secured lending activities – don’t deal with them.
- Fair advice: If you go through a broker (like Believe Loans or others), they are typically required to offer advice or an informed recommendation rather than just execution. That means they should explain why a particular loan is suitable for you. They also must inform you of any limitations (e.g., if they only work with a panel of lenders rather than the whole market).
- Documentation: You’ll receive full written terms (an offer document or ESIS) before signing the credit agreement. Read this carefully – it outlines the interest rate, whether it’s fixed/variable, the term, fees, your monthly payment, and any conditions.
- Cooling-off: After you sign, there is generally a cooling-off period (usually a few days) before the funds are released, giving you a short window to change your mind. However, it’s best to raise any issues before signing.
- Complaints process: Both banks and specialist lenders must have an internal complaints procedure. If you feel you’ve been mistreated or there’s an error, you can lodge a formal complaint with the lender. They have 8 weeks to respond. If you’re not satisfied, you can escalate to the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS), an independent body that can order compensation or corrective action. This applies to any regulated lender or broker.
- Property risk warnings: Every secured loan will carry the warning: “Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on a mortgage or any other debt secured on it.” This isn’t just boilerplate – it’s a serious reminder that defaulting on a second charge could lead to your home being at risk, just like defaulting on your main mortgage. So never borrow more than you’re comfortable repaying, and have a plan if things change (like interest rates rising).
Finally, be aware of secured loan scams or unregulated “loan arrangers.” Always use reputable, FCA-authorised firms. If a deal sounds too good to be true (like guaranteed approval or extremely low rates regardless of credit), be cautious. Stick with known high street institutions or vetted specialist lenders/brokers.
(Related read: “Using a Secured Loan Broker – What to Expect” – explains the role of brokers and how they are regulated.)
Which Option is Right for You?
Both high street banks and specialist lenders have a place in the secured loans market. The best choice depends on your individual situation, priorities, and profile. Let’s break down who might benefit from each:
High Street Banks – Best For:
- Prime Borrowers with Equity: If you have an excellent credit record, stable job income, and plenty of equity in your home, you’re the kind of customer banks want. You might secure one of the lowest secured loan rates from your high street bank, making it very cost-effective.
- Existing Mortgage Customers: Already have your first mortgage with the bank and they offer further advances? It can be convenient to top-up your borrowing there. You avoid setting up a whole new loan with another provider, and it might be simpler to manage one mortgage account.
- Small or Moderate Loan Needs: If you only need a relatively small amount (e.g., £10k, £20k) for a home improvement loan, and you qualify, a bank could be ideal. Banks often excel at straightforward, smaller loans (sometimes an unsecured loan might even suffice if your credit is great).
- Rate-sensitive Borrowers: If getting the absolutely lowest possible interest rate is your top priority and you have the credentials to qualify, start with high street options. For instance, if you’re borrowing a large sum and a bank offers 5% vs a specialist’s 7%, the savings in interest can be substantial over years.
- Simple Cases: If you don’t need any special flexibility (like interest-only payments, very long terms, or multiple drawdowns) and just want a plain vanilla loan, banks (if available) can do the job.
High street bank option summary: Best suited if you’re a perfect fit on paper and your bank is actually offering second charge borrowing. It’s about low cost and familiarity. However, many will find they either don’t qualify or their bank doesn’t offer what they need – which leads them to the specialist route.
Specialist Lenders – Best For:
- Those Declined by Banks: If you’ve been turned down by a high street bank for a secured loan or further advance, a specialist lender is the next stop. They actively serve customers that banks consider too risky.
- Adverse Credit Situations: Have a bad credit history but need to leverage your home equity? Specialists are known for bad credit second charge mortgages UK. While your rate will be higher, they provide an option to borrow when mainstream routes are closed.
- Self-Employed or Complex Income: Maybe you run a business, are a contractor, or have multiple income sources. High street banks might struggle with your affordability assessment. Specialists regularly work with self-employed secured loan applicants, using one year’s accounts or more flexible income calculations.
- Large Loan Amounts or High LTV: If you require a big loan relative to your home’s value, many banks won’t go there. Specialists might. For example, raising £150,000 on a £300,000 home (which is 50% LTV added to an existing first mortgage) might be possible with the right specialist lender, whereas a bank might have capped additional borrowing much lower.
- Debt Consolidation Plans: If the goal is to consolidate debt (credit cards, car finance, other loans) into one payment, specialists often advertise debt consolidation secured loans. They’re experienced in balancing the loan to clear various debts and may be more understanding of why your credit card utilization is high (since you’re paying them off with the loan).
- Need for Flexibility: Some specialists offer features like payment holidays, overpayment with no penalty, or interest-only periods (rare, but a few allow interest-only second charges under certain conditions). If you need any non-standard feature or a custom approach, a specialist is more likely to accommodate.
- Speed or Urgency: If you need funds quickly (perhaps for a business opportunity or urgent expense), a specialist route, often via a broker, could be faster than waiting on a bank’s process. They’re motivated to complete and have fewer bureaucratic hurdles.
In short, specialist lenders are a better fit for homeowners who don’t meet the strict mould of high street banks or who value flexibility and choice over brand name. They fill the gap in the market for secured loans for self-employed, credit-impaired, or otherwise non-standard cases, as well as large or specific borrowing needs.
Still not sure? It might help to discuss your situation with an advisor. Sometimes, a quick chat can reveal options you hadn’t considered. For example, a broker might say you actually could remortgage to a good rate instead, or confirm that “Yes, a specialist lender could be a better fit for your needs.” To explore this further, see our guide for self-employed secured loans which overlaps with many scenarios where specialists shine.
How to Compare Secured Loan Deals
Whether you lean toward a bank or a specialist, it pays to shop around and compare. Here’s how to go about it:
- Use a Secured Loan Broker or Comparison Service: A broker like Believe Loans (or others such as Loan Warehouse, Freedom Finance, etc.) can be extremely useful. They will take one application and compare secured loans across a wide panel of both high street (if any are offering) and specialist lenders. This saves you the legwork. Importantly, many brokers do a soft credit search at the enquiry stage, meaning you can see indicative offers without impacting your credit score.
- Compare Total Cost, Not Just Rate: Focus on the APRC and total repayable when comparing. A lender with a slightly higher interest rate but no fees might actually be cheaper overall than one with a lower rate but high fees. Look at the full picture: interest, fees, term, and any charges.
- Check the Terms: Some key points to compare:
- APRC (Annual Percentage Rate of Charge): This standardized rate helps compare overall cost including fees.
- Monthly Payment: Does it fit your budget comfortably?
- Term: How many years of paying? Shorter term means higher payments but less total interest; longer term means lower payments but more interest over time.
- Fixed or Variable: Is the interest rate fixed for a period or variable? If variable, consider that rates may rise in future.
- Flexibility: Can you overpay without penalty? Are there payment holidays? What’s the ERC if you settle early?
- High Street vs Specialist Quotes: If possible, get a quote from your current mortgage provider or bank and from a specialist lender (or via a broker) to directly compare. This way you have a direct second charge mortgage comparison UK between the two routes. Ensure both quotes are for the same loan amount and term for a fair comparison.
- Direct Lender vs Broker: You might be inclined to go direct to a secured loan lender thinking it’s cheaper (to avoid broker fees). However, many of the best specialist lenders operate only through brokers or intermediaries. Even for those that take direct applications, you may not get a better deal than through a broker – the interest rate and fees are often the same, because lenders set terms and may pay brokers a commission from their margin. A good broker will present the costs clearly. The advantage of using them is accessing many lenders at once and getting guidance. If you go direct, be prepared to do multiple applications to different lenders yourself (which could mean multiple credit checks). So, secured loan broker vs direct lender comes down to convenience and breadth of options vs doing it all yourself.
- Use Online Tools: There are online secured loan comparison tools (including on our site) where you can input your details and see deals you might qualify for. These are a great starting point to gauge what’s available. For example, our secured loan comparison tool lets you compare by loan size, term, and credit profile. Also consider tools to compare secured loans by total cost, which rank deals by the overall amount you’d repay.
Finally, once you’ve shortlisted some options, get professional advice. Secured loans are a big financial commitment, and an adviser can ensure you’ve considered all angles (including alternatives like a remortgage or even unsecured lending if the amount is small enough). Many advisors don’t charge you directly (they get a commission from the lender), so it’s worth taking advantage of their expertise.
Final Thoughts – Making an Informed Decision
Choosing between a high street bank and a specialist lender for a secured loan comes down to your unique situation. If you neatly fit high street criteria and value a slightly lower rate above all, your bank (if it offers secured loans) could be the way to go. However, if you need flexibility, have any sort of quirk in your profile, or just want to ensure you’re seeing all possible deals, specialist lenders via a broker will likely give you a better outcome.
In summary:
- High street banks offer familiarity, low rates for the most creditworthy, and convenience for existing customers – but they have limited products and rigid requirements.
- Specialist lenders offer a vast range of second charge mortgage options for all kinds of borrowers – more flexibility and higher loan amounts – but rates and fees can be higher especially if your credit isn’t perfect.
Always remember that a secured loan, whether from a bank or specialist, is secured against your home. This means you must be confident in your ability to repay it. Borrowing more has to be done sensibly – your property is on the line if you fail to keep up payments.
Before making a decision, do your homework: compare multiple offers, read the terms, and consider getting advice. The extra time spent can save you a lot of money and stress later on.
If you’re ready to explore your options, we’re here to help. Our platform allows you to start comparing secured loan options now, giving you a head start in finding the right deal – whether that ends up being through a high street name or a specialist lender. Make an informed choice and secure the loan that best meets your needs.
Frequently Asked Questions: Secured Loans
Are specialist lenders safe to borrow from?
Yes, specialist lenders are fully regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), just like high street banks. They follow the same rules around treating customers fairly and managing risk, even if they don't have a public-facing brand or branches on the high street.
Do specialist lenders charge higher rates?
Sometimes, but not always. Rates can be slightly higher to reflect added risk or flexibility. But if your situation is outside typical bank criteria, a specialist lender may offer better overall value - especially if they approve your loan when a bank wouldn't.
Can I apply directly to a specialist lender?
Some specialist lenders accept direct applications, but many work exclusively through brokers. A broker can help match your situation with the right lender, explain your options clearly, and often speed up the process by handling the paperwork and back-and-forth.
Are high street banks more likely to reject bad credit?
Yes. Banks typically use strict credit scoring systems, so applicants with missed payments, defaults, or CCJs are more likely to be declined. Specialist lenders often look beyond the numbers and assess applications based on your full financial profile, not just your credit history.
Which is faster - a bank or a specialist lender?
Specialist lenders often move quicker because they're built for flexibility and efficiency. Many use manual underwriting or work through brokers to speed things up. Banks can be slower due to rigid processes, several layers of approval, and more reliance on automated checks.
Articles that might interest you
Secured Loans for Business | Funding Growth with Your Assets
Looking to expand your business? A secured business loan lets you leverage personal or commercial property for capital. Fuel your business growth today.
Secured Loans from Believe Loans: A Full Review for UK Borrowers
Believe Loans is a licensed broker, specialising in secured loans from 90+ lenders. Discover how they can save you time and money in securing a loan. Clients are kept up to date at every stage of the application process, ensuring timely communication and transparency.
Best fast‑approval secured loans in 2025
Get the money you need in a flash - with serious flexibility and low‑stress approval.
The details shown are for illustration only and may not include all lenders or products. Actual rates and terms depend on your circumstances and the lender’s assessment. Information was correct at publication but may change at any time.
